The story of the imaginary unit, the number denoted by the symbol i, is often told with a simple, almost whimsical, beginning. It is presented as the answer to a playful question: what is the square root of negative one? This narrative suggests that mathematicians, in a fit of abstract curiosity, simply invented a new number to solve an equation that had no “real” solution, namely x2+1=0. This account, however, is a profound misrepresentation of one of the most fascinating and reluctant discoveries in the history of thought. The number i was not invented by choice; it was discovered by necessity. It emerged not from a simple quadratic puzzle but as an unwelcome, ghostly, and utterly baffling byproduct of a centuries-long quest to solve a far more concrete and pressing problem: the general cubic equation.
The true origin of the imaginary unit lies in a deep and frustrating paradox. In the 16th century, Italian mathematicians finally developed a formula that could solve cubic equations of the form x3+px=q. This formula was a monumental achievement, a key to a lock that had resisted the greatest minds for millennia. Yet, it contained a terrible flaw. When applied to certain cubic equations—equations that, by all visual and logical inspection, had three perfectly real, tangible solutions—the formula would inexplicably produce expressions involving the square roots of negative numbers. This was the infamous casus irreducibilis, the irreducible case. To find real-world answers, mathematicians were forced to take a detour through an impossible, imaginary realm. It was as if to calculate the distance between Rome and Florence, one’s map insisted on a route through the underworld.
This report will trace the dramatic and deeply human story of how these “sophistic,” “useless,” and “imaginary” numbers were forced upon a skeptical world. It is a tale not of serene academic inquiry, but of fierce personal rivalries, broken oaths, and profound philosophical struggle. We will meet the key figures in this drama: Gerolamo Cardano, the brilliant and tormented Renaissance polymath who first encountered these ghosts in his algebraic machine but dismissed them as “mental torture”; Rafael Bombelli, the pragmatic engineer who first tamed them, giving them rules and a purpose; Leonhard Euler, the master synthesizer of the 18th century who gave the number its modern name, i, and revealed its profound connection to the very fabric of geometry and analysis; and finally, Carl Friedrich Gauss, the prince of mathematicians, who gave it a firm and intuitive home in the two-dimensional plane, dispelling the last shadows of mystery.
This is the story of a number that nobody wanted but that mathematics demanded. It is a journey from a 16th-century intellectual feud to a 19th-century geometric revelation, demonstrating how the pursuit of the tangible can lead to the discovery of the abstract, and how a number once deemed imaginary became an indispensable tool for describing reality itself.
(more…)