Part I: The Genesis of Inquiry: From “Flying Saucers” to Government Scrutiny

The United States Air Force’s investigation into Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) was a direct response to several historical factors.¹ These included the anxieties of the Cold War, the dawn of the atomic age, and a sudden series of unexplained events in American skies.¹

This document argues that Project Blue Book was defined by a central conflict. It was simultaneously a public scientific inquiry and a confidential public relations tool. While its official purpose was to investigate, its primary function became managing public perception. This dual role inadvertently preserved a core of compelling, unexplained cases. These cases fueled decades of public distrust.¹

The official inquiry evolved through three phases: Project Sign, Project Grudge, and finally, Project Blue Book. Each was shaped by this foundational conflict, especially when faced with “high-strangeness” cases. These were reports so unusual in their details and witness credibility that they defied simple explanation.¹

1.1 The Summer of the Saucers (1947)

The modern UFO era began on June 24, 1947. Kenneth Arnold, a private pilot, was flying near Mount Rainier in Washington State. He saw nine bright, crescent-shaped objects in a V formation.¹ He estimated their speed at an incredible 1,700 mph, far faster than any known aircraft.¹,²

Arnold described their motion to reporters as “like a saucer if you skip it across water”.³,⁴ News editors shortened this to “flying saucers.” The term immediately entered the global lexicon.²,³,⁴ This somewhat whimsical name may have influenced early perceptions, possibly leading to a less serious initial investigation.

The term helped ignite a national craze. In the following weeks, a “flood of UFO reports” reached law enforcement and military offices.⁴ This fervor grew with the infamous Roswell incident in early July. The U.S. Army Air Forces first announced recovering a “flying disk,” then retracted the statement, claiming it was a weather balloon.²,³,⁵

The U.S. government’s main concern was not extraterrestrial visitors but a terrestrial adversary. Officials worried these sightings could be advanced Soviet aircraft.¹,²,³,⁵,⁶ The fear of a technological surprise that could threaten American air superiority drove the government to launch its first formal investigation.

1.2 Project Sign (1947-1949): An Open-Minded Inquiry

In response, the Air Force Chief of Staff ordered a new project. Its goal was “to collect, collate, evaluate, and distribute within the government all information concerning sightings which could be construed as of concern to national security”.⁴ This initiative, launched in January 1948, was codenamed Project Sign. It was based at Wright Field (later Wright-Patterson Air Force Base) in Ohio.⁴

Project Sign’s initial approach was one of genuine inquiry. Its staff was reportedly divided. Some believed in conventional explanations, while others seriously considered the extraterrestrial hypothesis (ETH).⁵ According to Captain Edward J. Ruppelt, who later led Project Blue Book, this debate may have led to a legendary, top-secret “Estimate of the Situation.” This document concluded the objects were real, technologically superior, and likely extraterrestrial.⁴ No official copy has ever been declassified, and its existence remains debated.⁴ The alleged document’s non-release continues to fuel skepticism about government transparency.

The project’s final, unclassified report was issued in February 1949 after reviewing 243 sightings.⁴ It was more cautious. It concluded that while most cases had ordinary causes, a number remained for which “no definite and conclusive evidence is yet available”.⁴ The report recommended that the investigation of all sightings should continue.⁴

1.3 Project Grudge (1949-1951): The “Dark Ages” of Debunking

Project Sign’s open-minded approach was short-lived. The conflict between genuine inquiry and public perception management led to a shift. In February 1949, Project Sign was replaced by Project Grudge, which had a very different tone and purpose.³,⁴ Officials had concluded that UFO reports themselves were a threat. They feared a foreign power could use them to cause panic and clog military communication channels.⁴

This new assessment changed the project’s mission. The primary goal of Project Grudge was not to investigate but to debunk. Its mandate was to “alleviate public anxiety” and persuade the public that UFOs were not unusual.³,⁴ Sightings were systematically explained away as misidentifications, illusions, or even “large hailstones”.⁴

The project’s only formal report, from August 1949, reflected this policy. It concluded that all UFO reports resulted from one of four causes:³,⁴

• Misinterpretation of conventional objects.
• A mild form of mass hysteria and war nerves.
• Hoaxes by individuals seeking publicity.
• Reports from “psychopathological persons.”

The report stated there was no evidence of advanced foreign technology and recommended reducing the investigation’s scope.⁴

Key figures heavily criticized this period. Captain Ruppelt called the Grudge era the “dark ages” of the investigation.¹ Dr. J. Allen Hynek, an astronomer and consultant, dismissed Grudge as “less science and more of a public relations campaign”.³ Though officially ended in December 1949, Project Grudge continued at a minimal level, leaving a legacy of institutional skepticism.³,⁴ These early projects set the stage for Project Blue Book, a larger but equally conflicted investigation.

(more…)