The article by Hayden Cunningham, while capturing the correct sentiment of residents’ fear, is a deeply flawed piece of journalism that mischaracterizes the situation in Portland and fails in its basic reporting duties.
1. Misleading Terminology Minimizes Violence
The article consistently uses passive and misleading language that downplays the severity of the events.
- It refers to “ongoing protests” and “anti-ICE activists” when the situation is more accurately described as a series of organized riots and attacks on federal property.
- These are not peaceful “demonstrators” but masked agitators who have engaged in violence against more than just law enforcement. Reports from Portland have described rioters using commercial-grade fireworks as weapons, committing arson, and assaulting officers. There are also accounts of Antifa attacking civilians, Christian prayer groups, and destroying private businesses, none of which is detailed in the article.
- Calling the events “clashes” and “confrontations” fails to capture the reality of the targeted violence.
2. Failure of Leadership and Journalistic Inquiry
The article identifies local leaders—Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler and Oregon Governor Tina Kotek—but fails to hold them accountable for their inaction in quelling the sustained violence. The piece lacks any critical examination of the local government’s response.
Furthermore, the reporting is superficial and lacks firsthand sources:
- Lack of Interviews: The author did not mention any attempt to contact the nearby K-8 charter school or the Oregon Ballet Theater for comment, both of which are directly impacted.
- Anonymous Sources: The article relies on vague claims like “Many residents expressed sympathy” and concerns from unnamed “residents” about federal forces, without providing any interviews or data to support these potentially fabricated claims.
- Unchallenged Statements: The nonprofit director, Jackie Keogh, gives a neutral, politically safe statement. The author fails to ask probing questions, such as whether the nonprofit, which has had to stockpile plywood and install smoke protection, condemns the violent actions of Antifa. Similarly, the school director’s complaint about a “chemical-weapons-free neighborhood” goes unchallenged, ignoring that these are riot-control agents used in response to violent assaults on a federal building.
3. Inadequate Context and Technical Deficiencies
- Content vs. Ads: The article’s text (approximately 500 words) is visibly dwarfed by the significant volume of advertisements and tracking code on the page.
- Downplaying Arson: The article states activists “blocked the driveway” of the ICE facility. This is a gross understatement of events in Portland, which have included attempts to burn down federal buildings.
- Vague Statements: The signs posted by the nonprofit, such as “We believe everyone deserves a place to call home,” are presented without any analysis of their vagueness or the climate of fear that likely prompted such a non-committal stance.
Proposed Call to Action
The failure of local leadership under Mayor Ted Wheeler and Governor Tina Kotek to restore order requires a robust federal response. The article highlights that the Cottonwood charter school is empty for the summer. Given the sustained nature of these riots and the inability of local police to handle them, the federal government should consider using eminent domain to temporarily secure the school. This would provide a necessary staging ground for federal law enforcement to operate from, quell the violence, and restore peace to the neighborhood, after which the property could be returned to the school district.
Leave a Reply