Cuban Doctors Abroad: Humanitarian Aid or State-Sponsored Espionage?

I. A Global Footprint: Strategy and Scale

Since the 1959 revolution, Cuba has sent its doctors and nurses around the world. What began as a revolutionary ideal has evolved into a massive, strategic global operation.¹,²

This report argues that Cuba’s medical missions have a dual nature. On one hand, they are a celebrated instrument of soft power and humanitarian aid. On the other, they function as a highly profitable state enterprise. This enterprise is built on a coercive labor system, which provides an ideal platform for intelligence gathering and political influence.

Key Statistics

Personnel Deployed: Over 400,000 Cuban healthcare professionals have worked in 164 countries since the program began.³,⁴
Active Missions: At any given time, between 22,000 and 50,000 Cuban health workers are active in over 50 nations.⁴,⁵,⁶,⁷,⁸
Global Scale: Cuba deploys more medical staff to the developing world than all G8 countries combined.⁹

These impressive statistics are not random. Cuba strategically chooses the locations of these missions to meet its geopolitical and economic goals.

Where the Missions Operate

Latin America (Mexico, Venezuela, Brazil)

This region is the program’s economic and ideological core. Venezuela hosted the most extensive deployment through the “oil for doctors” initiative. At its peak, this program involved over 31,000 Cuban medical staff sent in exchange for about 100,000 barrels of oil per day, cementing a critical alliance.⁹,¹⁰

In Brazil, the “Mais Medicos” program sent over 20,000 Cuban doctors to serve in poor and remote areas where local doctors refused to work.¹,¹¹,¹² The termination of this program by a new government showed how the missions depend on the host country’s politics.⁷,⁸

Mexico has also become a key partner, hiring thousands of Cuban specialists to fill gaps in its public health system.

Strategic Outposts (Russia, China)

Cuba’s engagement with major powers is more limited. In China, only a few dozen specialists have been sent for targeted roles like ophthalmology. In Russia, a 2025 proposal to import “tens of thousands” of Cuban medics to fix a doctor shortage has not yet led to a large-scale deployment. These smaller missions show that the program is tailored to specific relationships and needs.

The United States (A Point of Comparison)

An estimated 5,000 to 6,000 Cuban-born physicians practice in the U.S. These are not state-controlled mission doctors. They are individuals who emigrated and navigated the difficult U.S. relicensing process on their own. The rate of Cuban-born doctors in the U.S. is 9.4 times higher than that of Mexican-born doctors, relative to their immigrant populations. This disparity highlights a significant “brain drain” and contradicts the state’s narrative of selfless service.

A Two-Track Strategy

Cuba’s deployment strategy is a calculated one. It sends large, long-term missions to countries that offer political alignment (like Venezuela) or significant cash payments (like Mexico and Brazil).²,⁷,¹³

Simultaneously, it dispatches specialized “Henry Reeve Brigade” teams on short, high-visibility missions to disaster zones like Haiti or to wealthy nations like Italy during the COVID-19 pandemic.¹,¹⁴ This two-track approach allows Cuba to pursue its foreign policy goals: securing alliances, generating revenue, and building a global brand of “medical diplomacy.” The program’s global footprint, therefore, is not merely a map of medical need, but a map of Cuban foreign policy objectives.

II. The Economic Engine: How the Missions Make Money

Today, money, not ideology, drives Cuba’s medical missions. The state has transformed the program into a business designed to extract maximum revenue. This income provides an essential economic lifeline for the regime.

The Comercializadora de Servicios Médicos Cubanos (CSMC, S.A.), a state-owned corporation, manages the entire operation.¹⁵,¹⁶,¹⁷,¹⁸ The CSMC markets “professional services in the exterior” and signs contracts directly with host governments.¹⁵,¹⁶,¹⁷,¹⁸ Its corporate structure confirms its status as a for-profit business, not a humanitarian agency.¹⁵

A Model of Wage Confiscation

The business model is based on wage confiscation. It works in four steps:

A host country pays the CSMC a large fee for each doctor. In Mexico, this was reportedly around MXN 100,000 per month per doctor.
The Cuban state, through the CSMC, keeps between 75% and 95% of that payment.⁵,⁷,⁸,¹⁹,²⁰
The doctor receives only a small stipend, typically 10% to 25% of their salary, in the host country.⁵,¹⁴
The state might deposit a portion of the withheld salary in a Cuban bank account. However, doctors often cannot access this money until they complete their mission and return home, a policy that forces compliance.⁵,¹⁴

This system generates billions of dollars for the Cuban state. Experts estimate the annual revenue from professional services, mainly the medical missions, is between $6 billion and $8 billion.⁴,⁵,¹⁴,²¹,²² This makes the program Cuba’s single largest source of foreign income, far surpassing tourism.²,⁵

This focus on profit is a direct result of the economic crisis that followed the collapse of the Soviet Union. Facing economic ruin, the Cuban state realized its large number of trained doctors was its most valuable export. The state then commercialized the program under the CSMC to generate hard currency.²,¹⁹ The billions in revenue are the program’s primary purpose, funding the regime and offsetting the effects of the U.S. embargo. This economic dependency means that every aspect of the program is engineered for profit, making the system of control over its doctors a financial necessity.

III. Coercion and Control: The System of Exploitation

To protect its profits, the Cuban state uses a strict legal and administrative system to control its doctors abroad. This system of coercion is an essential feature of the program. It enables both the economic model and the potential use of missions for intelligence and political influence.

The Legal Apparatus of Control

The state formalizes its power through laws and regulations that strip medical professionals of basic rights.

Resolution 168 of 2010: Human Rights Watch describes this disciplinary code as imposing “draconian rules” that criminalize normal behavior.³ Key rules include:
- Restricted Friendships: It is an offense to have relationships with anyone holding “hostile or contrary views to the Cuban revolution”.³
- Restricted Movement: Doctors need “authorization” to attend public or political events.³
- Restricted Speech: Doctors need “authorization and instructions” to speak with the media.³
- Forced Reporting: Personnel must report all “romantic relationships” to their supervisors.³,²³
Cuban Penal Code: Article 176.1 makes “abandoning” a mission a crime. It is punishable by three to eight years in prison, turning a personal choice into a criminal act.³,²⁴,²⁵
Immigration Law: The state labels doctors who leave a mission as “deserters.” It then bans them from returning to Cuba for eight years.⁴,⁵,²¹ This policy of forced exile holds their families on the island hostage, creating powerful psychological pressure to comply.⁵,²⁹

On-the-Ground Enforcement

In host countries, these laws are enforced through direct operational measures.

Passport Confiscation: Supervisors commonly confiscate doctors’ personal passports upon arrival. They issue temporary “official” passports that prevent independent travel or seeking asylum.⁴,⁵,⁷,²⁹
Constant Surveillance: Brigades are monitored by “minders” who enforce curfews and report any signs of dissent. Colleagues are often pressured to watch one another.⁵,⁷,²⁹
Coercive Recruitment: Missions are officially “voluntary.” However, many former doctors report that refusing to go can lead to losing their job or being blacklisted in Cuba.³,⁵,²⁶ One complaint filed with the UN by former participants stated that 75% did not volunteer.⁵

This system has been widely condemned. The U.S. State Department has consistently ranked Cuba as a Tier 3 country for human trafficking, citing a “government policy or pattern to profit from forced labor”.¹³,²⁴,²⁵ UN Special Rapporteurs have stated the working conditions “could amount to forced labor”.⁴,⁷,²⁶,²⁷

The issues of forced labor and espionage are directly linked. An intelligence operation requires absolute discipline. A free workforce cannot be reliably forced to undertake clandestine tasks. By systematically removing options for refusal or flight, this coercive framework creates a disciplined and pliable workforce. It is the enabling infrastructure for the program’s use as a political and intelligence tool.

IV. The Covert Mission: Espionage and Political Influence

The state’s tight control over its medical personnel provides the perfect foundation for covert operations. Evidence suggests the program is used for intelligence gathering and political influence, consistent with the known practices of Cuban state intelligence.

A History of Dual-Use Missions

The program’s origins are tied to Cuba’s military and intelligence goals. The first mission to Algeria in 1963 included both medical staff and military officers.² Throughout the Cold War, medical brigades supported Cuban troops in Angola and Ethiopia and the Sandinista government in Nicaragua.²,²⁸

This context is critical when considering Cuba’s sophisticated intelligence capabilities. The Cuban intelligence service (DGI) has successfully placed high-level agents inside the U.S. government. These include Ana Montes at the Defense Intelligence Agency and Victor Manuel Rocha, a career U.S. diplomat.³¹,³²,³³,³⁴ This proves Cuba’s ability to run complex, long-term intelligence operations under deep cover. The medical missions provide an ideal vehicle for such operations on a much larger scale.

Intelligence Collection Under Medical Cover

Medical professionals have unique access to a host society. They often work in remote areas, away from government oversight.¹¹,²² Their jobs allow them to enter homes, interact with a wide range of people, and learn about local social dynamics. This is a perfect platform for gathering human intelligence (HUMINT). Under the cover of public health work, personnel can be tasked with mapping infrastructure, identifying local leaders, and gauging public opinion.

Case Studies in Political Interference

Venezuela: Defecting doctors have testified that they were forced to use medicine as a tool of political coercion. This included withholding care from opposition supporters and spreading propaganda for the Chávez and Maduro regimes.⁸,²⁹,³² Some were told to fake patient records to inflate the program’s success for political purposes.³⁵,²⁴,²⁹
Bolivia: In 2019, the interim government expelled over 700 Cuban doctors. It accused them of organizing protests to destabilize the country and restore former president Evo Morales to power.⁸
Brazil: During the Mais Medicos program, doctors reported being pressured to spread leftist propaganda.¹¹ The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) helped manage the program and was later criticized for its role in facilitating the exploitative financial arrangements.⁷,¹³
Mexico: The large-scale deployment of Cuban doctors has raised concerns among security analysts and politicians. They point to Cuba’s history of embedding intelligence agents in such delegations.³⁶

Embedding Intelligence Officers

Reports from organizations like Cuba Archive state that some brigade members are actually military and intelligence officers operating under medical cover.² Their dual mission is to conduct intelligence operations and to enforce discipline within the brigade itself.

The operational model relies on the program’s massive scale. The vast majority of the 30,000-plus personnel are genuine doctors working under duress. This large group of legitimate medical workers creates a “haystack” of humanitarian activity. Within this haystack, the Cuban state can hide a few “needles”—trained intelligence officers or medical professionals coerced into spying.² This provides plausible deniability, as any accusation of espionage can be countered by pointing to the thousands of patients being treated.

Table 4.1: Profile of Cuban Medical Missions in Key Host Nations

Country	Program Name/Agreement	Approx. Personnel (Peak)	Stated Financial Arrangement	Reported Labor/Human Rights Conditions	Documented Allegations of Political/Intelligence Activities
Venezuela	Barrio Adentro / Oil-for-Doctors	31,000+	Barter: Medical services exchanged for ~100,000 barrels of oil per day.⁹,¹⁰	Extreme coercion, constant military supervision, passports confiscated, wages rendered worthless by hyperinflation.²⁹,³⁰	Systematic: Withholding medicine for votes, spreading pro-regime propaganda, falsifying medical statistics for political gain.⁸,²⁹,³²,³⁵
Brazil	Mais Medicos (More Doctors)	20,000+	Host gov’t paid PAHO, which paid CSMC. Doctors received ~10-25% of salary.⁷,¹²	Passports confiscated, families prohibited from joining, lawsuits filed by doctors alleging slave-like conditions.⁷,⁸	Spreading leftist propaganda; program terminated by Bolsonaro government on political/labor grounds.⁷,⁸,¹¹
Mexico	IMSS-Bienestar Agreement	3,100+ deployed, more planned	Host gov’t pays CSMC directly. Approx. MXN 100k/mo per doctor, with CSMC retaining majority.	Details less public, but subject to the same Cuban legal framework (Resolution 168).	Concerns raised by analysts and opposition about embedding of intelligence agents.³⁶
Bolivia	N/A	700+	Direct payment to Cuban state.	Doctors reported receiving only one-third of promised salary.⁸	Direct Intervention: Accused by the post-Morales government of fomenting protests and engaging in political destabilization, leading to expulsion.⁸
Italy	COVID-19 Emergency (Henry Reeve)	~50	Billed as humanitarian aid; financial terms not fully public.	High-profile deployment, likely with less overt coercion due to visibility in a Western nation.	No public allegations of espionage; primary mission was soft power generation and propaganda.¹,¹⁴

This table shows that the program is a flexible tool. In an allied state like Venezuela, it acts as an extension of the regime’s security apparatus. In a country like Brazil or Mexico, the focus is on making money. In high-visibility deployments to Western countries, the mission is almost purely for public relations. This adaptability underscores its primary function as an instrument of statecraft.

V. Geopolitical Chess: The Missions as a Tool of Foreign Policy

The medical missions are one of Cuba’s most powerful foreign policy tools. They allow the small nation to project influence far beyond its economic weight.

The program achieves several key goals:

Public Relations and Soft Power: The missions create an image of a small nation providing a global public good. This generates international goodwill that helps “whitewash” Cuba’s poor domestic human rights record.³⁸,³⁹,⁴⁰
Diplomatic Support: Cuba turns this goodwill into political support. The missions help build alliances, which translate into favorable votes at the United Nations on resolutions condemning the U.S. economic embargo.² For many small nations, Cuban doctors are essential to their healthcare systems. This creates a dependency that Havana can leverage for political support.⁹,³⁸ The Prime Minister of Saint Lucia admitted that the country’s “medical system would basically collapse without them”.³⁷
Countering U.S. Influence: By filling public health gaps in the developing world, Cuba positions itself as a reliable alternative partner to the United States.³,³⁹ The offer to send 1,500 doctors to New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina was a masterful political move. It was designed to highlight the failures of the U.S. government while showcasing Cuban competence—a direct challenge to its “eternal enemy”.⁹,¹¹

Through these strategies, Cuba uses its medical personnel as strategic assets to carve out a sphere of influence, challenge U.S. hegemony, and secure its political survival.

VI. The Official Story: Crafting Cuba’s Counter-Narrative

The Cuban government has a strong and consistent narrative to defend the medical missions from criticism. This story is a key part of the program’s strategy, designed to provide political cover and discredit accusers.

Havana’s official position rests on three main points:

The missions are acts of pure humanitarianism and solidarity with the world’s poor.²²,²³
The revenue generated is not profit. It is reinvested to fund Cuba’s own free, universal healthcare system, which struggles under the U.S. embargo.²²
All criticism is a politically motivated smear campaign. The United States leads this campaign to discredit Cuba and tighten the embargo.³,²¹,²²,²⁹,³⁴

State-controlled media, like the newspaper Granma, pushes this narrative. It calls critics “intolerant, conservative voices” reading from a U.S. script.²² It praises the doctors as “heroes” and “volunteers” who willingly contribute their earnings to support their homeland.²²,²³

A Fundamental Contradiction

However, this official story has a major contradiction. The claim that billions in revenue are used to fund the domestic health system is disproven by the reality of that system’s decline. Reports show severe shortages of doctors, decaying hospitals, and a “brain drain” of thousands of medical professionals fleeing the island.⁴¹

These two facts—the claim of reinvestment and the reality of domestic collapse—cannot both be true. If the multi-billion-dollar revenue were truly funding the domestic system, that system would not be in crisis. This contradiction strongly suggests the money is being diverted to other state priorities, such as funding the security and intelligence services and maintaining the regime’s power. The poor state of healthcare in Cuba is perhaps the strongest evidence against Havana’s official claims.

VII. Strategic Assessment and Recommendations

Cuba’s international medical mission program is a sophisticated and cynical tool of state power. While it provides real health benefits to underserved communities, this humanitarian work serves as a cover for three primary goals:

Economic Survival: The program is a business that generates an estimated $6 to $8 billion a year, making it the Cuban state’s most important source of revenue.
Geopolitical Influence: The missions are a soft power tool that builds international goodwill, secures diplomatic support, and counters U.S. influence.
Covert Operations: The program’s structure and the coercive control over its staff provide an ideal platform for intelligence gathering and political influence.

The entire system depends on state-sponsored exploitation that meets the international legal definitions of forced labor and human trafficking. The coercive framework of restrictive laws, passport confiscation, and surveillance is a deliberate structural element. It guarantees the state’s control over its personnel and their income, and it is what enables their use for clandestine purposes. The system of forced labor is the operational infrastructure for espionage.

Recommendations for Host Countries and International Bodies

Any country or organization engaging with Cuba’s medical missions must do so with extreme caution.

Demand Transparent ContractsHost governments must insist on transparent contracts that comply with international labor laws.Why it’s crucial: This moves beyond opaque state-to-state agreements and ensures individual rights are legally protected from the outset.
Guarantee Labor Rights and Direct PaymentA non-negotiable condition must be the direct payment of full, market-rate salaries into the personal bank accounts of the doctors. Host countries must guarantee their rights to freedom of movement and association and ensure they keep their own passports.Why it’s crucial: This directly dismantles the state’s model of wage confiscation, which is the core of the exploitative system.
Vet and Monitor PersonnelHost governments must vet all incoming personnel and monitor mission activities.Why it’s crucial: This protects national security and prevents the host country’s healthcare system from being used as a platform for political interference.
Hold Facilitators AccountableInternational organizations like the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) must be held accountable for any role in facilitating programs that involve forced labor.Why it’s crucial: Involving international bodies in exploitative schemes lends them a false legitimacy; accountability is necessary to uphold international labor and human rights standards globally.

In conclusion, the flow of Cuban doctors is not simple migration or humanitarian aid. It is the strategic deployment of state assets in a global enterprise where medicine is the product, profit is the motive, and political power is the ultimate prize. Host nations must recognize that in contracting these services, they risk becoming complicit in a system of state-sponsored human trafficking.

Works Cited

British Institute of International and Comparative Law (BIICL). “Combatting Forced Labor in Cuban Medical Missions.”
Cuba Archive. “Overview of Cuba’s Medical Brigades.” October 2022.
Human Rights Watch. “Cuba: Repressive Rules for Doctors Working Abroad.” July 23, 2020.
U.S. Department of State. “Human Trafficking in Cuba’s Labor Export Program.” August 22, 2024.
U.S. Department of State. “Trafficking in Persons and Cuba’s Labor Export Program.” January 20, 2025.
Associated Press. “Cuban diplomat defends foreign medical missions under pressure from US.” June 17, 2025.
U.S. Congress. “S.2138 – Combating Trafficking of Cuban Doctors Act of 2021.” June 17, 2021.
Smith, M. “Communist Cuba Enslaves Physicians.” Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation. December 25, 2019.
Wikipedia. “Cuban medical internationalism.”
Policy Center for the New South. “Cuban Medical Assistance: A Diplomatic Tool.”
Huish, R. “The Cuban Revolutionary Doctor: The Ultimate Weapon of Solidarity.” Monthly Review.
Al Jazeera English. “What’s the future for Brazil’s healthcare after Cuban doctors’ exit? | The Stream.” YouTube.
U.S. Congress. “H.Res.1446 – Denouncing the human trafficking and forced labor of and profiteering from Cuban medical personnel serving in third-world countries.” September 12, 2024.
Guttman, C. “Is Cuba’s ‘Army of White Coats’ Medical Diplomacy or Contemporary Slavery?” Cornell Business. May 19, 2021.
Comercializadora de Servicios Médicos Cubanos (CSMC), S.A. “Somos SMC.”
Prensa Latina. “Comercializadora de Servicios Médicos Cubanos, S.A.” June 12, 2021.
Comercializadora de Servicios Médicos Cubanos S.A. “Catálogo Institucional.” YouTube.
Edumed Holguin. “Comercializadora de Servicios Médicos Cubanos S.A. (CSMC).”
Kirk, E.J., and M.J. Brouwer. “Cuba’s Health Security Capacity: its sources and the social controls that underpin it.” PMC (PubMed Central). May 15, 2020.
Share America. “The truth about Cuba’s medical missions.”
U.S. Department of State. “2024 Trafficking in Persons Report: Cuba.”
Granma. “Cuban doctors welcomed for good reason.” June 8, 2020.
Borgen Magazine. “Cuban Doctors: From Heroes to Victims.”
U.S. Embassy in Cuba. “2025 Trafficking in Persons Report: Cuba.”
U.S. Embassy in Cuba. “Human Trafficking in Cuba’s Labor Export Program.” 2024.
Civil Rights Defenders. “Cuban Doctors Abroad at Risk of Human Rights Violations.” April 24, 2020.
Prisoners Defenders. “622 testimonies show the pattern of mass slavery in the «Internationalist Missions» of Cuba.” September 22, 2020.
Cuba Archive. “Overview of Cuba’s Medical Brigades.” (Duplicate of #2).
The World. “Cuban medical missions face scrutiny amid allegations of forced labor.” July 15, 2025.
U.S. Department of State, New York Foreign Press Center. “A Call to Action: First-Hand Accounts of Abuses in Cuba’s Overseas Medical Missions.” September 26, 2019.
Wikipedia. “Julius and Ethel Rosenberg.”
CBS News. “Spies for Cuba a danger to U.S. national security as American secrets sold around the world | 60 Minutes.” YouTube.
60 Minutes. “How Cuban spies evaded American intelligence for decades.” YouTube.
CBS News. “How Cuban spies like Ana Montes and Victor Manuel Rocha are recruited and why they’re so hard to catch.”
Pulitzer Center. “Cuban Physicians Still Abandoning Missions Abroad Despite End to U.S. Parole Program.” March 12, 2018.
Harvard Review of Latin America. “A Playground for International Spies: A Look at Mexico.”
Government of Saint Lucia. “Prime Minister Responds to US Inquiry on Cuban Doctors.”
SIT Digital Collections. “Medical Diplomacy as a Form of Geopolitical Power: A Case Study on the Republic of Cuba.”
Pettinà, V. “The ‘White Coat Brigades’: Cuba’s Medical Missions Between Idealism and Praxis.” Equal Times.
Feinsilver, J.M. “Cuban Medical Internationalism and South–South Cooperation.” International Journal of Cuban Studies. Vol. 15, No. 2. Winter 2023.
Sanchez, R., and L.C. Da Silva. “Cuban doctors working abroad: a risk to health care at home?” PMC (PubMed Central). September 2, 2006.